Is Your Roofing Solution in Shingles or Tabs?

BP & GAF Architectural shingle side-by-side

Roofing Materials Today

Manufacturers make modern roofing from laminated compounds with color added. There are two basic types, which are essentially either a single-layer or a double-layer roofing tile. The double-layer roof tile is the architectural or dimensional type. The single layer is the three-tab version.

The architectural type is costlier but more appealing to the eye, and it can add value to your home. The single-layer type or three-tab tile is a basic roof cover. It has a flat appearance, and the tiles are consistent in size and shape.

Construction of Asphalt Roofing

Damaged three tab shingle roof
3 tab shingles installed on a roof showing damage

The inner core of each tile is a piece of fiberglass. The fiberglass is water-resistant and provides some insulation. The maker then sandwiches the sheet of fiberglass between two weatherizing layers. Next, the top layer receives a covering of mineral granules, which add texture and color.

The architectural type of roof tile is a double of the four composite layers. The lower edge of the architectural tile has a raised laminated ridge. This raised section adds to the appearance of depth.

The double-layer composite tile is a popular roof cover. Manufacturers call it architectural or dimensional roofing. You can distinguish the architectural type from a three-tab or single-layer tile by its size, weight, durability, and appearance.

Asphalt Composition

Asphalt is the base material for architectural or double roofing and the 3-tab types. In the early 1980s, technical advances in lamination and materials created the architectural type. From that time to the present, architectural types have replaced tabs as the preferred material for roofing installations. Today, the traditional three-tab type of roofing is the low-cost option and the required material to repair roofs that already have tab shingles. 

When estimating the number of shingles needed to cover a roof area, Roofr uses technologically advanced methods to obtain precise measurements. Roofr will utilize satellite imagery to determine the exact roof dimensions and to estimate the bundles needed to complete the work on your home. 

Architectural shingles have depth and dimension

Advantages of Architectural Roof Covers 

The double-layer roofing tiles have a noticeable multidimensional surface. The tiles stand out for their contours and depth. You can get them in shapes and colors that resemble high-end materials, like baked tiles, cedar shakes, and slate tiles. The advantages of double-layer tiles include: 

  • Durability: Double-layer roofing lasts longer and maintains its appearance better than single-layer materials. While the costs of acquisition may be higher for double-layer roofing, the longer life and added value for your home can pay for the added investment.
  • Appearance: The double-thick roof types have the appearance of depth. They add value to homes because of their popularity and eye-catching results.
  • Wind resistance: The thick tiles do not resist the wind better than the thin tiles until they seal. Single-layer tiles traditionally have ratings of up to 80 miles per hour. The manufacturer's warranty requires a 6-nail installation pattern for a high-wind damage rating of up to 130 miles per hour.
  • Warranty: Manufacturers typically provide warranty coverage in the range of 40 to 50 years. The latest warranty trends also include a lifetime coverage for as long as you own your home.

Begin the Roofr process and discover the solutions we have for your roofing needs and style preferences.

Get Started Free

How to get a roofing quote for your asphalt shingle house

When it comes to roofing projects, there are a lot of possible mark ups, be it supplies, hour premiums or just higher rates for contractors. There are a lot of factors that can go into you getting the overall price for your repair or replacement. If you had the chance to simplify this tedious task would you? Our simple solution for you is to use our free roofing estimate tool

It's tough to find a reputable roofer


Quotes and estimates can be one of the most confusing parts of the roof repair process. Whether it’s a number that just can’t manage to stop fluctuating, or a contractor that keeps finding extra costs to tack on last minute, it can be a bit nerve wracking when it comes to picking which quote to settle on. This process alone can take weeks.

With the Roofr estimate tool, it only takes seconds to use, and it will give you a free estimate instantly. We will then contact you within 24 hours to create an appointment for one of our professional contractors to come to you for your onsite analysis. This analysis is to provide the contractor with all the information about your specific roofing project, and the overall condition of your roof.

We connect homeowners to vetted roofers to bid on roofing projects

Once our professional has gone over all of your roofing needs with you, we will provide you with a firm quote. No hidden fees, no surprise mark ups, just your quote, plain and simple.

If you decide the price is right for you, then we will move forward with your roofing project. With the work done and your complete satisfaction with the results, you pay your contractor, and the job is done.  

Putting a roof over your head shouldn’t be such a stressful task, so let us simplify it for you. 

Get Started Free

GAF Timberline VS BP Mystique asphalt shingle comparison

Shingle Comparison chart for your reference, compare GAF Timberline to BP Mystique shingles.

GAF Timberline shingles and BP Mystique shingles are an architectural fiberglass asphalt shingle used all across North America on residential homes. It is always recommended that you have GAF Timberline shingles installed by a GAF certified roofer. BP has similar certification programs for their approved roofing contractors.


GAF Timberline 

BP Mystique

Visual Style Timberline_Ultra_HD_Charcoal.jpg mystique-east-2-tone-black-su164632.png
Warranty 50 year limited lifetime warranty/10 years non-prorated  50 year limited lifetime warranty/15 years non-prorated
Wind Rating 110 mph wind warranty  110 mph wind warranty
 Weight 210 lbs / 100sqft 237 lbs / 100sqft
Actual Lifetime 30-35 years  25-30 years
19   19
 Bundles/Pallet 36 36
  • Timberline Ultra HD - BarkwoodTimberline Ultra HD - Barkwood
  • Timberline Ultra HD - Biscayne BlueTimberline Ultra HD - Biscayne Blue
  • Timberline Ultra HD - CharcoalTimberline Ultra HD - Charcoal
  • Timberline Ultra HD - Fox Hollow GrayTimberline Ultra HD - Fox Hollow Gray
  • Timberline Ultra HD - HickoryTimberline Ultra HD - Hickory
  • Timberline Ultra HD - Hunter GreenTimberline Ultra HD - Hunter Green
  • Timberline Ultra HD - Patriot RedTimberline Ultra HD - Patriot Red
  • Timberline Ultra HD - Pewter GrayTimberline Ultra HD - Pewter Gray
  • Timberline Ultra HD - ShakewoodTimberline Ultra HD - Shakewood
  • Timberline Ultra HD - SlateTimberline Ultra HD - Slate
  • Timberline Ultra HD - Weathered WoodTimberline Ultra HD - Weathered Wood


Improper installation of asphalt shingles can cause leaks and void your manufacturer warranty.

Contact Roofr to schedule a visit from one of our vetted professional roofers.

Get Started Free

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *